Membership sites are easy to start – and they are all around, as a business or passive income.
Hobbyist cinema lovers sharing deep-cut film analysis, professional training centers selling certifications and ongoing education, etc. The model looks perfect and attractive to many people: it offers recurring revenue, loyal audiences, and scalable growth. You want to start it as a side hustle and grow into a full-sale business.
The sad truth is that many membership sites quietly stall or shut down within the first 90 days. You can find countless stories of nervous breakdowns and disappointment from founders who started with high hopes but eventually quit. Why?
Typically because a few very common (and very human) mistakes pile up.
Below, we’ll take a closer look at the most common reasons membership sites fail, categorized clearly, and we’re also trying to elaborate on how to fix each one.
This is written for people who are already struggling or are just about to start a membership site and want to avoid painful lessons.
They Don’t Treat It Like a Real Business
This is a common strategic and mindset failure.
Many membership sites start as passion projects:
- “I love this topic.”
- “People keep asking me for advice.”
- “I’ll just record a few videos and see what happens.”
You will see many people on social networks who keep saying that you should follow that initial inspiration – but not everyone explains how fragile it can be.
A good analogy is people enrolling in online courses. Enrollment is often impulse‑driven, motivation ready to move mountains. But unless the course is extremely engaging or the learner is unusually disciplined, most people never finish.
Running a membership site works the same way!
Without forward thinking, with a purely inspiration-driven start, you are going to face this:
- Your energy drops
- Your consistency breaks
- Your audience feels it immediately
What’s the solution?
Even if your goal is “just passive income”, you still need structure and help. The best case – you’ve been in a real validated business like this as a team player before. And it’s not something you know nothing about in terms of managing it.
Actually, in real businesses, founders rarely do everything themselves forever (unless they want a burnout soon).
Treat your membership like a business by:
- Creating simple to‑do lists (weekly, not someday).
- Defining minimum deliverables (what must exist even on low‑energy weeks).
- Delegating early.
- Have a plan for a moment when inspiration feels like a weak foundation (be mindful).
- Create new habits.
If you want this to stay passive long‑term, your role must become slightly more passive too, but not your responsibility as a strategic thinker and planner.
They Don’t Create Consistent Engagement Routines
A very common pattern for this is community and retention failure. You release a great video or start a discussion; get a few comments… Then… silence for three or four weeks?
During that gap, members might stop checking in, and your site becomes forgettable.
What’s the solution?
You need routines and more or less predictable engagement loops (it’s more about consistency than intensity). Those might include weekly content drops (even small ones), monthly meetings or webinars, and scheduled discussions.
Your goal is not to entertain constantly, it’s to focus member energy on your platform instead of letting it drift elsewhere.
They’re Using the Wrong Software (Or Too Little of It)
Well, today, software is not “just software” for some automation or operational staff. For membership sites, it’s your:
- Structure
- Monetization engine
- Marketing assistant
- Motivation system
Without the right tools, you create an operational hell for yourself when you need to manually take care of things like emails, access, renewals, or support calls. What kind of joy are we talking about here then?
What’s the solution?
Use software that actively supports growth. Modern membership tools like ARMember do far more than lock content.
They help you:
- Create drip content to build anticipation.
- Set up leaderboards and gamification for motivation.
- Sell full membership plans or paywall specific pages.
- Automate renewals, access rules, and user management.
- Reduce phone calls and manual support.
Additional features especially useful for membership sites include:
- Multiple membership tiers.
- Trial periods and discounts.
- Built‑in reporting and analytics.
- Content restriction by role, plan, or behavior.
The right software only helps you improve your passive income or a core revenue stream.
Not Enough Members in the First 90 Days
There can be a financial and momentum failure, too. Low early numbers hurt more than just revenue. They damage your motivation, confidence, and willingness to reinvest.
When growth feels flat, every task feels heavier.
What’s the solution?
Plan for delayed profit on purpose because membership sites rarely explode instantly. This means – try to plan your resources with the assumption that first profits are delayed and early months are about validation, not income.
That means:
- Budgeting for at least 3-6 months of low returns.
- Separating emotional success from short‑term numbers.
- Tracking engagement before obsessing over revenue.
They Overwhelm Members With Too Much Content
Remember, we were talking about consistency in releasing content and interactions? This has nothing to do with spamming members.
One of the reasons membership sites fail is cognitive load failure. Even valuable content feels too much and annoying when you bombard members with it… Choice, not pressure.
What’s the solution?
Stick to an adequate consistency and probably make engagement optional, not pushy.
Inside your membership site, you can offer optional reading clubs, create discussion boards people can dip into, and allow members to self‑select depth.
Improved retention – longer life for your membership.
They Don’t Understand Real Member Journey
There might be a UX and membership onboarding failure that prevents your business from growth. New members log in… and don’t know what to do first. They see too many sections, no obvious starting point, no sense of progress – all this confusion kills motivation at the start.
What’s the solution?
Design a simple path that brings members from A to Z, understand how full onboarding feels, and whether they have obstacles. Every membership needs a clear “Start Here” path, defined milestones, and visible progress. People stay when they feel movement.
The Topic Has Little or No Market Demand
Quite often the problem is simple – a market validation failure. Some ideas are interesting.
Some are meaningful. But not all are monetizable. A topic can be too niche, too broad, too easily available for free.
What’s the solution?
Validate before you scale! Before building deeply, test paid demand, pre‑sell access, look for recurring problems. A small but hungry audience beats a large indifferent one.
Not Enough Subscription Options
A membership site might simply have a pricing and audience segmentation failure. One price fits almost no one.
Your audience likely includes various levels and various budgets, so try offering fitting solutions for:
- Beginners
- Advanced users
- Casual learners
- Professionals
What’s the solution?
Try to diversify membership options. Consider multiple tiers, monthly vs annual plans, and content‑only vs community‑included access.
Weak, Lazy, or Inappropriate Marketing
For some good membership site ideas, the reason for failure might be a growth and visibility failure because of poor marketing.
Common issues are inconsistent promotion, wrong channels, messaging focused on features instead of outcomes. Marketing is an ongoing channel and should be taken care of just like content or activities you create.
What’s the solution?
Analyze channels and market the transformation:
- Who it’s for.
- What changes after joining.
- Why staying matters.
Founders Try to Do Everything Alone
It’s a sustainability failure, then. Even if it’s a one-man project for passive income, you still should delegate or automate a lot of processes.
Burnout shows up as skipped weeks of new releases, shortcuts, and resentment toward your own project. Don’t allow it.
What’s the solution?
Don’t postpone support, such as automation, freelancers, or community moderators.
Summing up: Why Do Most Membership Sites Fail in 90 Days ?
The magic number of 90 days is not a precise measure, but a psychological barrier – when initial inspiration becomes fragile, a membership site founder’s motivation sinks due to a lack of outcomes or profits, or when ideas start to feel like they aren’t working.
Yes, many membership sites don’t fail because of one big mistake. They fail because of small, unaddressed issues that come over time, and because founders are psychologically unprepared to deal with routines or face obstacles.
You need to arm yourself with structure, intention, and the right tools to fight the enemies behind why most membership sites fail within 90 days. Treat your membership like something worth sustaining – because if you do, your audience will too.
Related articles:
Share this post
