Have you ever told yourself, “I’ll start tomorrow,” and then somehow three weeks pass?
Most of us have. We save the workout plan, bookmark the course, download the app, and feel pretty good about it. Then life gets busy, and that motivation quietly disappears.
An online challenge can change that.
Give someone a clear goal, a few simple steps to follow, and a finish line they can see….suddenly, taking action feels a lot easier. And when other people are doing it with them? Even better.
That’s what makes online challenges so useful for online communities. They give your members something to work toward, a reason to come back, and a lot of opportunities to interact with your membership site.
And you can turn almost anything into a challenge: completing a course, creating content, building a habit, joining discussions, or simply showing up consistently.
So, if you’ve been looking for a simple way to get your members more involved, an online challenge for members can be exactly what your membership site needs.
Below, I’ll show you how to host an online challenge for members, plus some simple (yet effective) challenge ideas and membership engagement strategies.
TL;DR: To host an online challenge for members, pick a clear goal, break it into simple tasks, set a manageable schedule, and keep members engaged with progress updates, rewards, and community interaction. In WordPress, tools like ARMember can help you manage content, member access, gamification, and community features throughout the challenge.
What Kind of Online Challenge Should You Run?
Before you start planning daily tasks, rewards, emails and all the other moving pieces, you need to decide what kind of online challenges you’re actually running.
Think about what you want your members to do by the end. Do you want them to build a habit? Finish something? Get involved in your community? Reach a specific goal?
Now, before jumping to any conclusion, let me tell you this answer varies by the type of community you own. Mostly, you’ve heard of fitness challenges yet that’s just one niche. There are multiple types of online challenges that work for different industries and scenarios such as.
In short, online challenges for members work best in niches where members are looking for transformation, lifestyle shifts, habit-building, or skill acquisition.
Here’s are some of the membership industries and niches where online challenges can work like a game changer:
- Health, fitness and wellness: This is the most natural fit for challenges because the goals are highly quantifiable and habit-driven.
- Business, Career and Finance: Professionals and entrepreneurs love challenges because they break complex business strategies into daily steps.
- Creativity, Hobbies and Arts communities: Creative niches thrive on challenges because they combat creative block and force members to practice regularly.
- Lifestyle, Parenting & Personal Development: Memberships built around life and family dynamics benefit greatly from structured community driven accountability.
Once you know this, choosing the right challenge for members gets much easier.
Time-Based Challenges
Sometimes, a deadline is all someone needs to finally get started.
A time-based challenge gives your members a set number of days or weeks to complete a series of tasks. It could be a 7-day challenge, a 14-day sprint or a 30-day challenge.
For instance, you can ask members to spend 10 minutes learning something new every day for 7 days or complete one lesson from your course each day for a month.
These challenges work well when you want members to build consistency.
Community-Based Challenges
Some challenges work best when members can see that other people are taking part too.
Let me break this feeling down for you: What happens when you run in a race all by yourself? Chances are, you’ll feel motivated because you enjoy it, but in the long run, you’ll also start losing that motivation. Why? Because running alone in a race is not a race at all (nor fun).
A community-based challenge gets members talking, sharing progress, posting updates and encouraging each other along the way.
For your membership site, you can run a weekly discussion challenge, a photo sharing challenge, a “share your progress” challenge or even a friendly competition between members.
The goal here is simple: give people something to do together.
Goal-Based Challenges
Got a specific result you want your members to reach?
A goal based challenge gives them something concrete to work toward.
That could mean completing an online course, writing 10 blog posts, creating their first digital product, reading five books or finishing a particular project.
These challenges are great when your members already know what they want to achieve and simply need a little structure to get there.
Which Challenge Is Right for Your Members?
Now comes the fun part: picking your challenge.
As I said earlier, the right online challenge depends on your membership industry and niche.
Thus, start with your members. What are they trying to achieve? Where do they usually get stuck? What could give them a reason to take action this week?
Also, you can mix these formats. A 30-day fitness challenge can be goal-based and community driven. A course completion challenge can have a time limit and a leaderboard.
There’s always a lot of room to make the format your own. Just keep the challenge simple enough that members know exactly what they’re signing up for.
How to Plan Your Membership Online Challenge
You’ve picked the type of challenge. Now it’s time to figure out what actually happens after members join.
This is where a good membership challenge can become confusing if there are too many tasks, too many rules or too many things for members to remember. Too many is never good for anything.
So, keep the experience simple from the start.
Start With One Clear Goal
What should members accomplish when the challenge ends?
That answer should be easy to say in one sentence.
Maybe you want members to complete an online course, get a daily habit, publish their first five posts or become more active in your community.
Give your challenge one main goal and let everything else support it.
Don’t Make the Challenge About Five Things
It’s tempting to pack everything into one challenge. But don’t do that.
You want members to learn something, complete your course, post in the community, invite a friend, earn points, and maybe even buy another product while they’re at it.
That’s a lot to ask!
Your members should be able to look at the challenge and understand quickly what they need to do. Keep the main action clear and save the extra stuff for later.
Decide What Members Need to Do
Now break that big goal into small actions.
If your challenge is about completing a course, members might need to finish one lesson each day. If it’s a content challenge, they might create one post every morning.
Think about the smallest action that moves members closer to the finish line. The easier it is to understand, the easier it is to start.
Choose the Right Length
How long should your challenge run?
There’s no magic number here. A quick habit-building challenge can work well for 7 days, and a bigger goal could need 30 days or more. So simply think of how much work you’re asking members to do and how often you want them to come back.
If the challenge feels like a second job, you will lose people before they reach the end.
Give Members a Clear Finish Line
Members should know exactly when they’ve completed the challenge.
A clear finish line gives the whole experience a sense of progress. It also gives you a natural moment to celebrate their achievement, hand out rewards, or guide them toward what they should do next.
And that last part matters.
A challenge shouldn’t simply end with “Congratulations!”. You’ve just spent days getting members active. Give them a reason to keep going.
Make Your Challenge Schedule
Now you know what your members need to do and how long the challenge will run.
So of course, the next step is to put everything into a schedule your members can actually follow.
No worries, this doesn’t have to be a complicated in-detail plan for every single day. We’re trying to make a challenge here, not a strict military discipline plan.
Just give each day or week a clear purpose, then decide what members should see, do, and complete at that point.
| Challenge Stage | What to Include | Example |
| Before the Challenge | Welcome message + instructions | Explain how the challenge works |
| Day 1 | First task + quick win | Complete the first lesson |
| Days 2–6 | Daily tasks + progress checks | Complete one task each day |
| Midpoint | Motivation + progress update | Share a progress post |
| Final Day | Final task + celebration | Complete the challenge |
| After the Challenge | Reward + next step | Give a badge and recommend the next activity |
There’s still more to this and that is to keep your schedule easy to understand. Your members should be able to open the challenge and know EXACTLY what they need to do that day.
Keep Members Engaged Throughout the Challenge
Getting members to join your challenge is one thing. Getting them to stick around until the end is where the real work begins.
A few members might happily work through the challenge on their own. Others may need a little nudge when the starting “first-time” excitement wears off.
That’s exactly why many growing membership systems offer automated reminders, progress updates, rewards, and a place for community interaction.
Celebrate small wins along the way. Ask members to share their progress. Give them something to look forward to at the next stage.
You can also add a little friendly competition. Of course, if it fits your community. A leaderboard, points, badges, or simple shout-outs can make progress feel more visible.
The key is to keep giving members a reason to come back and take the next step.
How to Run an Online Challenge in WordPress
You’ve planned the challenge, mapped out the schedule, and figured out how to keep members moving. Now you need a way to actually run the whole thing on your membership site.
If you’re using WordPress, ARMember gives you a lot of tools to manage your member experience from start to finish. This WordPress membership plugin comes with 62+ in-built addons alongside a modern, SaaS-like user interface to get you moving in no time.
Keep Content Flowing With ARMember Drip Scheduling
You probably don’t want members opening your challenge on day one and seeing everything at once.
With ARMember Drip Scheduling, you can release challenge content as per your schedule. Members can get the next lesson, task or piece of content when they’re ready for it.
That makes it much easier to guide members through a 7-day, 14-day or 30-day challenge.
Reward Every Win With ARMember In-built Gamification
Even small wins deserve a little recognition.
ARMember’s in-built Gamification features let you add points, badges and other rewards to your challenge experience. Members can see their progress and have something to work toward as they complete activities.
This makes those small wins feel worth celebrating.
Bring Members Together With Social Community Addon
Want to make challenges more engaging? Let members see what others are up to.
With the ARMember Social Community Addon, make a place for your members to talk, share updates and discuss their progress. Afterall, it’s always better to be together and stronger side by side.
Overall, that turns your online challenges for members into a shared experience where members can encourage each other and stay involved throughout the challenge.
Give Members the Right Access Using Advanced Content Restriction
Not every member needs access to every part of your challenge at the same time.
ARMember’s Advanced Content Restriction lets you control who can access specific areas of content based on your membership rules.
You can use it to make sure members see the right challenge content at the right stage. And also keep the restricted lessons or resources available only to the members who should see them.
5 Online Challenge Ideas You Can Try For Your Membership Community
You’ve got the plan. You know how to structure the challenge and keep members moving. Now you just need an idea that fits your community.
Here are five you can try, whether you want to help new members get started, encourage participation or get people to finally finish something they started.
7-Day Welcome Week Sprint
Give new members a reason to explore your membership site during their first week.
Create one small task for each day: complete their profile, introduce themselves, check out a key resource, join a discussion or finish their first lesson.
By the end of the week, they’ve seen what your membership has to offer and, hopefully, started feeling at home.
30-Day Content Creation Challenge
Have members create something every day for 30 days.
It could be a blog post, social media caption, video, design, email, or anything else that fits your community.
Keep the daily task small enough to complete without spending hours on it. Also, members can share what they create with the group and pick up ideas from each other.
Course Completion Race
How many members have bought an online course and then quietly forgotten about it?
Give them a reason to finish.
Set a deadline for completing a course or a specific number of lessons. You can add points, badges, or a leaderboard to make the race more exciting.
Everyone works toward the same finish line, and your members get more value from the content they already have.
Caption This Contest
This one is simple and can get your community talking quickly.
Post an interesting, funny, or unusual image and ask members to come up with the best caption.
Let members vote on their favorites and give the winner a small reward. You can run it as a one-day activity or make it a weekly community challenge.
Peer Accountability Groups
Sometimes, having someone else waiting for your update is enough to keep you going.
Split members into small accountability groups and give everyone a shared goal. Ask them to check in regularly, share their progress and encourage one another.
It can work well for fitness, learning, business, writing or any challenge where members benefit from having someone in their corner.
What to Do When the Challenge Ends
Your challenge is over. Everyone has reached the finish line. Time to pack everything away and move on, right?
Not quite.
The end of your online challenge is actually a great moment to keep that momentum going.
Start by celebrating the members who completed it. Give them their rewards, highlight some of their achievements or simply share a few of the best moments from the challenge.
Then ask what they thought. What did they enjoy? Where did they struggle? What would they change next time?
You can use those answers to make your next challenge even better.
Most importantly, give members somewhere to go next. Recommend another online course, invite them to the next community challenges, introduce a related membership site challenge, or give them another goal to work toward.
That way, the challenge becomes part of your member journey.
Final Words: Ready to Run Your Own Online Challenge?
It’s now time to put these challenge ideas into action and run your own online challenge for members!
Pick an online challenge style that fits your membership business, give it your own twist and don’t worry about getting everything perfect from day one. Your first membership community challenge is a chance to learn what works.
Plus, pay attention to how your members participate, what keeps them coming back, and where they need a little extra motivation or support. You can later use those insights smartly to make your next challenge even better.
Ready to host your own online challenge? With ARMember and a little creativity, you have a great place to start.
Related articles:
Share this post
